Tuesday, September 25, 2012


Book Review

Title: Cuba Confidential – Ann Louise Bardach

Publisher: Random House - 2000

Author Ann Louise Bardach captivates an audience with poise and authenticity through the prism of a wrecked vessel and the least expected survivor and lead actor Elian Gonzalez. Like the investigative A&E television program City Confidential the plot is riveting in topography, villains and victims yet departs on interpretation of decency which is largely ascribed to political ideology, social experiences and geography.

The book revisits causation surrounding a failed and unauthorized attempt by two families and friends to travel the Florida Straits by boat to American prosperity. It accurately dissects each individual and contributes a descriptive tale of affection, comradeship and personal desires as the bedrock of this adventure that ran amuck. The story is relived by shipmates Arianne Horta and her boyfriend Nivaldo Fernandez but eclipsed by the emergence of the 6 year old boy and orchestrated by his handlers, grand uncle Lazaro Gonzalez, his uncle’s daughter Marisleysis, congresswoman Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, the Cuban American National Foundation (CANF) and the extended Cuban-American community in Southern Florida.

Bardach uniquely hones her craft articulating the utilization of paternity to exasperate antagonistic flames towards the Cuban establishment. Central to this discussion is the role of the CANF, its founder Jorge Mas Canosa and Washington in alliances of ill repute unveiled by participants and techniques of a questionable nature employed to dislodge the Castro administration. The illustrious and ruthless leader of the Cuban government in exile who is incriminated by associates for countless encounters with known felons most notably drug dealers Rafael de Arce and Antonio Canaves and Bay of Pigs operative Luis Posada Carriles is quoted as saying, “We will never forget our friends and will always remember our enemies” and therefore unwaveringly thwarts an exchange of ideas on transition in Cuba.

Regrettably disparaging battles of admonishment were waged unsparingly against fellow Cuban-Americans who defied the odds in Miami as the foundation’s overwhelming power silenced many, permeated the airwaves and even the White House and the national legislature where it bore the rare distinctions of influencing American foreign policy with presidents Ronald Reagan, George H. Bush, William Clinton and George W. Bush and congressional representatives Robert Menendez, Robert Torricelli and company. Hence ironically the deportment of the accusers unmistakably embodies hypocrisy as malignant deficiencies of intolerance are hallmarks shared with their Caribbean adversaries. 

Not to be overshadowed by philosophical assertions is also revelation of family connections between members of the Cuban leadership in South Florida and Havana. Castro’s indifference and subsequent divorce from his first wife Mirta Diaz Balart, the sister of Rafael Diaz Balart a former cabinet member of the Batista regime and aunt to congressman Lincoln Diaz Balart and the sunshine state senator Mario Diaz Balart ferments personal vendetta towards the maximum leader.

Balanced assessments incorporate precision in analysis of Cuba through the lens of its messiah and local observers. Such invites extensive interviews seeking to untangle the web of an individual of privileged means and an incomprehensible personality; upper-class childhood, brilliant student, uncommitted father, philander, revolutionary and maniac.

A tapestry of Castro’s life relays an ambivalent relationship with family members, a disdain for the status quo, and efforts to micro- manage marriage simultaneously with application to political protest. Unsurprisingly despite age and the passage of time the polarizing commander in chief vocalizes with zest socialism, its accomplishments, shortcomings, the US propaganda campaign inclusive of assassination attempts and is unremorseful for executions and imprisonments in contradiction with principles of the revolution. Conversely others reference a system adherent to a personality cult and a psychopath clueless to reality by underscoring immigration and decay on the domestic front.

The writer artistically interweaves politics as an overarching theme in explicating the characteristics of the underworld and its links to government. Accounts provided by Posada charged the CIA as a covert instrument of recruitment and training for clandestine outfits namely the Junta Revolutionaria Cubana, the Cuban Representation in Exile and the Commandos of the United Revolutionary Organizations aimed at destabilizing Havana and aired his dubious past with Orlando Bosch a convicted terrorist and former governor of the province of Las Villas.

An extended network also engulfed Latin American safe havens and/or launching pads such as Argentina, Mexico, El Salvador, Panama and Venezuela, and surrogates Hernan Ricardo and Freddy Lugo, the accomplices of the 1976 Air  Cubana bombing and Frank Castro and Felix Rodriguez among others. Moreover in light of shifting currents in Grenada and Nicaragua, the Reagan-Bush presidencies received recognition for ambiguous endorsements and commitments as demonstrated by Secretary of State Alexander Haig, National Security Advisor Robert McFarlane to annihilate Cuba.

Following a crescendo that embroiled local fanfare and a fiasco fueled by the media, courts, defense attorneys and politicians the pronouncement of justice was met with a possibility for reflection. With the loss of political leverage and Elian’s return to his homeland the text reveals a political fallout and disintegration staged by Team Florida.

The once cohesive CANF displayed signs of fragmentation. Nonetheless an appeal for moderation aligned with the ascension of Jorge Mas Santos, the son of the late Mas Canosa was subject to reproach from former affiliates Radio Marti and Radio Mambi accompanied by personalities the likes of Ninoska Perez-Castellon, Alberto Hernandez and Jose Antonio Llamas and isolation by congresswoman Ros-Lehtinen’s former campaign manager and recent governor Jeb Bush. Further as anticipated the democratic party and particularly Janet Reno became instant targets for retaliation and later suffered humiliating losses at the polls in 2000 and 2002 respectively. In contrast victory on the island was punctuated with official events and rewards to the Gonzalez family. It was indeed a repeat of David versus Goliath as Castro triumphed over his archrival.

Cuba Confidential is a “must read” for scholars and laypersons as well. It’s thought provocative portrayal of comparable inconsistencies and extremes prevailing on both sides of the divide beckons for reason by moderators fixated on political identities and limited by distrust. 

Leroy A. Binns Ph.D.
Adjunct Professor: The Graduate School of Arts and Sciences
The Union Institute

No comments:

Post a Comment